Catskill cryogenic rescue highlights winter hiking risks

The late start, extended route and icy terrain led to long nights and hypothermic rescues in the Catskills. The incident highlights how little room for error exists on winter hiking, even if hikers are prepared.

On a recent afternoon in January, a hiker began climbing Table Mountain from the Phenicia East Branch. It's very late. A ranger on patrol expressed concern about the timing, but the hikers felt prepared and had the proper gear and chose to keep going. It's easy to relate. Many winter hikers start late but feel strong and trust their experience.

Over time, the plans expanded. Instead of a single peak, this hike has grown into a multi-peak itinerary, including Butte Mountain, Picamos, Table Mountain, and the Rockies. This type of decision-making is common when a situation feels manageable early on. However, in the winter, every additional mile and every additional descent increases the risk. Darkness came faster than expected. The trails take longer to complete. In the summer, seemingly easy-to-control off-route exits become treacherous.

Find your dream trip in the Catskills

The only directory dedicated exclusively to Catskill vacation rentals.

Find your Catskill accommodation

The hiker fell into the Neversink River while trying to escape in the early hours of the morning and sent a distress signal via satellite equipment. Fisherman's Roada pathless route used by many Catskill hikers. In winter conditions, hikers were completely submerged and soon began to suffer from hypothermia. When rangers reached them hours later, the situation had become serious due to icy road conditions. Fortunately, dry clothing, heat, and hot liquids stabilized the hikers enough to get out.

Catskills cry for help

What is striking about this incident is not the carelessness. Hikers have gear. They have confidence. They have enough experience to try multiple peaks. The problem is a series of small decisions made late in the day when winter profits are slim.

Winter changes math. The distance feels longer. Exiting the route is more difficult. Border crossings can quickly turn from an inconvenience to an emergency. One mistake can ruin hours of good judgment.

There's an important lesson here that doesn't require finger-pointing: Winter plans require tighter boundaries than summer plans.

Start time is more important. Backup routing needs to be conservative. Ambitious add-ons should be considered optional, not assumed. Perhaps most importantly, confidence should be combined with early intention. turn around.

Winter mountaineering doesn’t require perfection. It does require humility. Each season teaches this lesson in a different way. Winter often teaches it quietly after dark, when the woods are cold and rescue is far away.

source: DEC press release
Denning Township/Ulster County/Wilderness Rescue:

At 1:30 pm on January 16, ranger Jeffrey was conducting a routine patrol along the Phenicia East Branch Road when he encountered a 33-year-old man who was hiking on Table Mountain. Ranger Jeffrey expressed concern about the late start, but the hikers continued on, confident in their abilities and equipped with the appropriate gear. At 2:27 a.m., hikers from Hopewell Junction sent out a distress call via satellite equipment, with coordinates on Fisherman's Trail, which runs parallel to the Neversink River. This is a common pathless exit route on many Catskill peaks. Icy road conditions delayed ranger response times. At 6:30 a.m., rangers Franceschina and Jeffery found the hiker, whose body temperature had apparently plummeted after falling into the river and becoming completely submerged. The rangers quickly changed the hikers into dry clothes, used heating blankets, and provided hot beverages. After talking to the hiker, they learned that the hiker changed their plans to include Lone, Peekamoose, Table, and Rocky Mountains. Rangers assist hikers to the trailhead and advise them to seek further medical attention if they experience any swelling, blisters or discoloration. 8:30 a.m. Resources are available

Read more